The Republic of Talamthom
    > The High Court of the Republic
        > A query,
New Topic    Add Reply

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author
Comment
James A Grieve 
Uachtarain na Tománn
President of Talamthom
DLP

Posts: 145
(29/6/05 21:43)
Reply

A query,
LCJ Gladstone,

I felt I should probably consult the Courts on this one, as it's a bit of a sticky issue which the Government could probably use some legal advice on.

If you have read my recent posts in the Dáil, you will have noticed that I have called on Dáil ministers to ratify the Constitution, again. Since we have lost all our legislation, I really feel we need to do more than just dredge up copies from disk caches and/or our memories -- this seems to be the best way (short of using the Citizen's Council, which could well turn into a total fiasco) to give the recovered Acts some sort of legality.

Your opinion would be much appreciated, your honour.

Regards,

James A Grieve (DLP)
President of the Republic
Poblacht na Tománn

Kevin Gladstone 
Lord Chief Justice Judge
Tománnach Citizen

Posts: 573
(1/7/05 15:44)
Reply

Re: A query,
Mr President,

Thank you for your query. The relevant article for ratifying/amending the constitution is Article 14:

Quote:
Article Fourteen - Amending the Constitution
1. Constitutional amendments may originate in the Dáil or Citizens' Council.
i. The Dáil must assent to all amendments by majority of those voting, rounded up to the nearest whole citizen.
ii. The Citizens' Council must assent to all amendments by two-thirds supermajority of those voting, rounded up to the nearest whole citizen.


In view of the technical problems we have experienced recently and the fact that there were several versions of the constitution in circulation before the crash, I think it wise to have the Dail ratify one of the versions so that we have an authentic constitution to rely upon.

Kevin Ewart Gladstone
Lord Chief Justice

Thomas O Ceallaigh 
Former President of Talamthom
11/06/04 - 19/06/05
Citizen of Talamthom
Knight of Gotzborg and ALexandria
DLP

Posts: 1751
(1/7/05 22:24)
Reply

Re: A query,
I think this is the best course of action also.

___________________________
Tomás Seosamh Ó Ceallaigh,
Uachtaráin,
Áras na Uachtaráin,
Baile na hÁlainn,
Poblacht na Tománn

James A Grieve 
Uachtarain na Tománn
President of Talamthom
DLP

Posts: 169
(3/7/05 17:48)
Reply

Re: A query,
Your Honour,

The vote in the Dail Tomann closes at 0800 BST Monday, and looks to be unanimous in favour of the current version, which I will circulate to replace the various existing copies asap.

In light of the fact that this is technically not an ammendment, do you believe it necessary to endure yet another period of absenteeism-wracked voting in the Citizen's Council, or can we consider the matter settled at 0800?

With respect,

James A Grieve (DLP)
President of the Republic
Poblacht na Tománn

Kevin Gladstone 
Lord Chief Justice Judge
Tománnach Citizen

Posts: 574
(4/7/05 4:53)
Reply

Re: A query,
Mr President,

In the opinion of this Court this is a ratification rather than an amendment and as such does not need submitting to the Citizens Council.

Kevin Ewart Gladstone
Lord Chief Justice

Thomas O Ceallaigh 
Former President of Talamthom
11/06/04 - 19/06/05
Citizen of Talamthom
Knight of Gotzborg and ALexandria
DLP

Posts: 1759
(4/7/05 21:23)
Reply

Re: A query,
Thank goodness for that!

___________________________
Tomás Seosamh Ó Ceallaigh,
Uachtaráin,
Áras na Uachtaráin,
Baile na hÁlainn,
Poblacht na Tománn

James A Grieve 
Uachtarain na Tománn
President of Talamthom
DLP

Posts: 176
(7/7/05 1:57)
Reply

Re: A query,
I agree with Tom on this, phew.

Though the Constitution received only two votes in this action, both were in favour. As such it has been unanimously 'ratified'.

Thanks for your assistance, LCJ.

Regards,

James A Grieve (DLP)
President of the Republic
Poblacht na Tománn

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Email This To a Friend Email This To a Friend
Topic Control Image Topic Commands
Click to receive email notification of replies Click to receive email notification of replies
Click to stop receiving email notification of replies Click to stop receiving email notification of replies
jump to:

- The Republic of Talamthom - The High Court of the Republic - Poblacht na Tománn -

Powered By ezboard® Ver. 7.32
Copyright ©1999-2007 ezboard, Inc.