Liontamer's Lair
    > Entertainment and Chat Forum
        > Kurt Cobain
New Topic    Add Reply

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>
Author
Comment
Crawl
Registered User
(7/12/01 4:41 pm)
Reply

Kurt Cobain
Why is it that whenever Kurt Cobain is mentioned in connection with guitarists, people always act like he was a bad guitarist? Let's see, between him and Eddie Van Halen, I don't think there's much question between who soloed the fasted. But which one wrote the better songs?

Facilitypro 
Moderator
(7/12/01 9:26 pm)
Reply

Re: Kurt Cobain
Kurt is like the Punchout of music. He didn't use a whole lot of technique, but he did very much with what he used.

Kurt was actually a pretty competent guitar player, technically speaking. It's just that the songs he wrote had no place for flashy solos and such. Granted, he was no Van Halen speedwise, but I've heard some rare tapes of Kurt playing bluesy-type stuff, and it sounded very well. But yeah, some people make him out to be about as good as someone who just learned power chrods.

That reminds me of Kim Thayil of Soundgarden. He played fast solos, but he didn't use any scales, per se. He once said it was funny to hear people call him a great guitarist.
It's pretty easy to get a Kim Thayil-like sound with a Wah pedal and some fast but fairly aimless picking. You can see (err...hear) some of Soundgarden's influence on Nirvana's Incesticide, namely the solo to Aero Zeppelin.

Crawl
Registered User
(7/13/01 12:06 pm)
Reply

I LOVE FO!
You covered most of what I could say. I think Kurt had a good sense of rhythm and melody and other technical qualities. But what really made him a great guitarist is the degree his phrasing let him put emotion into his playing. Speed isn't what separates a great guitarist from a good one; feeling is. I imagine that if some more flashier guitarists covered Kurt's songs that they wouldn't be able to make the material sound as "alive" as Kurt could.

I like Soundgarden... but one song of theirs in particular I don't like is Black Hole Sun. I think it's my least favorite song of theirs, at least of those I heard, which is somewhat ironic, considering it was their biggest hit.

<< Prev Topic | Next Topic >>

Add Reply

Email This To a Friend Email This To a Friend
Topic Control Image Topic Commands
Click to receive email notification of replies Click to receive email notification of replies
Click to stop receiving email notification of replies Click to stop receiving email notification of replies
jump to:

- Liontamer's Lair - Entertainment and Chat Forum -

- Contact Administrator - Register An Account - Find Other ezboards -
Vote for me in The Game Pond's Top 50 Sites!




Powered By ezboard® Ver. 7.32
Copyright ©1999-2007 ezboard, Inc.